Forward-looking petition plan for the 10th triennial anticircumvention rulemaking (NPRM mid-2026, Final Rule ~Oct 2027).
This page formalizes a five-new-class petition strategy for the 2027 cycle, plus streamlined renewals of every 2024 grant. Each filing is structured around a cohesive user community and an evidence record modeled on the closest 2024-granted class — the Office's own pattern.
The 2024 Register denied "commercial and industrial equipment" broadly (Proposed Class 5, broader scope) for the same reason it denied Proposed Class 12 in 2021: stated as "insufficient record + non-cohesive class." Read the Office's grant pattern across cycles and the actual decision variable is record depth: the "non-cohesive class" framing is largely pretext used to deny when the record is thin. Wins in 2024 — food-prep (b)(16), medical-device (b)(17), vehicle/vessel data (b)(14) — all turned on concrete, named, documented use cases combined with a tight copyright posture. Our work-around: (a) split the rulemaking record into cohesive user communities (not equipment categories), (b) develop the record before filing, not after, and (c) use specific equipment examples to build per-category record depth — the diversity of examples is the argument for the class's breadth, not an argument against it. The 2017 §1201 Study itself (PDF p. 94) "recommends against limiting an exemption to specific technologies or devices."
Full strategy document with witness lists and class-language drafts: 1201/Claude Reports/2026-05-23__2027-Cycle-Multi-Class-Petition-Plan.md. Citations to the Register's reports keyed to 1201/Claude Reports/2026-05-24__Office-Policy-Reports-and-2027-Plan-Implications.md.
The Register has already endorsed the substance of what we're petitioning for. The 2017 §1201 study (Section 1201 of Title 17 — A Report of the Register of Copyrights) recommended to Congress a permanent statutory exemption for diagnosis, maintenance, and repair under §1201(a). The 2016 software-products study (Software-Enabled Consumer Products) found that §117 of the Copyright Act and existing doctrines (fair use, idea/expression, merger) already cover the underlying copyright activity in repair. Together the reports give us four citations that pre-rebut the most common opposition arguments:
1. The Register supports a permanent repair exemption. "A limited and properly‐tailored permanent exemption for [diagnosis, repair, and maintenance], including circumventing obsolete access controls for continued functioning of a device, would be consistent with the statute's overall policy goals." — 2017 §1201 Study, PDF p. 90. The Office said the rulemaking is a "somewhat ill‐fitting regulatory approach" (p. 92) for cross-cutting repair issues. Our triennial filings are interim relief while Congress catches up.
2. The Office expressly recommends against device-specific limitations. "The Office recommends against limiting an exemption to specific technologies or devices, such as motor vehicles, as any statutory language would likely be soon outpaced by technology." — 2017 §1201 Study, PDF p. 94. This is the Office's own position that broader, cross-device repair exemptions are preferable. Cite it whenever opposition argues a class is "too broad."
3. Safety concerns belong outside copyright. "To the extent that commenters oppose an exemption for repair out of non‐copyright related concerns, such as public safety, the Office believes these matters are better addressed through laws or regulations outside of the Copyright Act." — 2017 §1201 Study, PDF p. 94. The Office's own framing for our Filing 5 safety carve-outs.
4. §117(d) is the Register's preferred statutory anchor for "maintenance" and "repair." The Office recommended that any repair exemption use §117(d)'s definitions: "the 'maintenance' of a machine is the servicing of the machine in order to make it work in accordance with its original specifications" and "the 'repair' of a machine is the restoring of the machine to the state of working in accordance with its original specifications." — 17 U.S.C. §117(d); 2017 §1201 Study, PDF p. 94. Our class-language drafts should mirror this. The "original specifications" framing also pre-rebuts the modification / tinkering objection: we are not asking to enhance or customize devices, only restore them.
What's NOT in our favor: the Office rejected a §1201(a) infringement-nexus requirement (would weaken copyright owners' control over online access to creative works, 2017 Study pp. 42–46) and rejected categorical exclusion of "device- or machine-enabling computer programs" (line-drawing problems, p. 47). Our argument cannot be "TPMs on repair targets are categorically outside §1201"; it must be "these TPMs are non-creative-works gating and the Office has endorsed the repair-exemption framework."
| Date | Event | Our action |
|---|---|---|
| ~Jun–Jul 2026 | NPRM published | Stop scope changes; freeze filing list |
| ~Aug–Sep 2026 | Petitions due (30–60 days post-NPRM) | File all 5 new-class petitions + renewal batch |
| ~Dec 2026 | Round 1 (initial) comments due | The deadline that matters. Full evidence record per class |
| ~Mar 2027 | Round 2 (opposition) comments due | Triage which filings face opposition |
| ~Jun 2027 | Round 3 (reply) comments due | Reply on contested filings only |
| Summer 2027 | Public hearings (if called) | Witness prep for top 2–3 filings |
| ~Oct 2027 | Final Rule | Accept; convert denials into 2030 record-building TODOs |
Extends the (b)(13) motorized-land-vehicle pattern to (a) stationary agricultural systems and (b) construction-equipment clarification.
(b)(13) "motorized land vehicle" reaches excavators, loaders, dozers, mobile pavers.§201.40(b)(13) motorized land vehicle (repair-class template); (b)(14) vehicle/vessel data (data-access analog if needed).(b)(N) class covering stationary ag + stationary construction processing; on-record clarification that (b)(13) reaches mobile construction.Repair of software-enabled scientific and laboratory instruments — every category of research instrument, from mass spectrometers to electron microscopes to sequencers. The 2024 Class 5 proponents (Public Knowledge & iFixit Initial Comment, PDF p. 9) explicitly excluded "devices designed or marketed for medical, scientific, or consumer use" from their petition — meaning the §1201 record on scientific equipment is clean and unopposed. This filing closes that deliberate gap with a comprehensive record across the full surface of research instrumentation.
As with every filing in this portfolio: these are examples that build the per-category record. The class itself is scientific and laboratory equipment broadly — naming specific instrument types is record depth, not a list of separate asks.
§117(a) "should adequately protect most repair and maintenance activities" (p. 35). The 2017 §1201 Study went further and recommended Congress adopt a permanent statutory repair exemption using §117(d)'s "maintenance" and "repair" definitions. Even the joint opposition coalition (AAP, ESA, MPAA & RIAA) conceded in the 2016 record that "automobile repair or other forms of repair might present a unique and distinguishable set of circumstances" (2017 Study at p. 93 n.508). Scientific instruments fit that distinguishable-set framing exactly.§201.40(b)(17) medical-device repair — closest pattern: same ISO-repair industry structure, same "related data files" issue (calibration files, run-method files), same professional/institutional user posture. (b)(16) retail commercial food-prep — analogous "institutional commercial user" template.(b)(N) for scientific and laboratory equipment repair, with related-data-files coverage (calibration files, run-method files) on the (b)(17) model.Anchored to the post-CHIPS-Act political moment: domestic factory owners need autonomy over their own operations to ramp up American manufacturing. Covers the full envelope of equipment a U.S. factory needs to operate — production lines, factory-floor automation, fab tooling, and manufacturing-facility infrastructure. Same substantive ask as the post-2024 industrial-automation strategy, reframed around reshoring and operator sovereignty, with selective scope expansion into adjacent fab infrastructure.
§201.40(b)(17) medical devices (professional / institutional repair under firmware control); (b)(21) 3D-printer feedstock (adjacent, does not reach device repair). Adverse: 2021 Proposed Class 12 + 2024 Proposed Class 5 (broader scope) denials — the re-industrialization framing is the strategic response to those denials.Hardware repair under firmware lockout across the full general-purpose computing stack — from consumer-grade laptops used commercially through professional workstations through datacenter hardware. The (b)(15) consumer-device class's "primarily designed for use by consumers" gate is genuinely ambiguous for PCs / Macs / laptops used in commercial settings — this filing closes that gap explicitly, and folds enterprise IT in alongside it under a unified "hardware repair, not software access" framing.
(b)(15)'s "consumer" gate by design and marketing.Why these exclusions are doctrinally important. The 2016 Software Study draws a distinction we explicitly track: embedded software that is "invisible to the consumer" (mechanical controllers, peripheral firmware, parts-pairing chips) is owned for §117(a) purposes, but software that is "a more significant element of the transaction" (an OS like macOS or Windows) is more likely treated as licensed (PDF p. 35–36). Our scope sits squarely on the owned-firmware side of that line — we're asking to circumvent component-authentication chips so the user can replace failed hardware, not to access or modify the OS. The exclusions above make that distinction explicit so opposition cannot conflate the two.
(b)(15) reaches devices "primarily designed for use by consumers." Commercial-use PCs and workstations sit outside that gate by both design intent and marketing. The 2012 SFLC PC-repair denial is 13 years old; the evidentiary landscape has changed completely (Apple Silicon parts-pairing, locked SSDs, T2 / secure-enclave authentication, surface bonding). A direct ask for general-purpose computing in commercial use rests on a much stronger record than 2012's, and on a class-definition theory that does not exist in any current exemption.§201.40(b)(15) consumer-device repair (analogous for non-commercial PCs; this filing extends the same logic to commercial use); (b)(17) medical devices ("professional repair under firmware control, including related data files" template for the enterprise IT leg).(b)(15)'s consumer gate). The narrow framing — hardware repair only, no licensing / OS access / content-DRM bypass — is essential.(b)(15) already covers and decline to extend). Datacenter / enterprise gear: likely denied at full scope; narrow abandoned-vendor IT carve-out plausible (parallel to Filing 3b).One broad class covering software-enabled equipment installed on commercial, institutional, and multi-family premises that uses TPMs to gate physical repair. The diversity of equipment categories below is not an argument for separate filings — it is the evidence that this is a single systemic problem affecting one coherent user community (operators of commercial premises). The breadth of the class follows from the breadth of the record.
(b)(15)'s home-systems leg.(b)(16)'s food-prep class — institutional kitchens, hotels, factories.These are examples, not a menu of separate asks. Each contributes to the record showing the same TPM-gating-repair pattern across the full surface of commercial-premises equipment.
Note for the opposition: the 2017 §1201 Study explicitly directs safety arguments away from copyright: "to the extent that commenters oppose an exemption for repair out of non‐copyright related concerns, such as public safety, the Office believes these matters are better addressed through laws or regulations outside of the Copyright Act" (PDF p. 94). Our carve-outs above implement that direction; safety regulation belongs to UL, IEEE, EPA, DOE, and AHJ inspection — not §1201.
§201.40(b)(13) vehicle/vessel (vehicles have safety-critical components; the Office accepted "restore original specifications" repair); (b)(16) food-prep (commercial-operator user community); (b)(17) medical devices (related-data-files pattern); (b)(15)'s home-systems leg (analog for the residential side of the same equipment categories). All four 2024 grants support the framing.(b)(N) for software-enabled commercial-premises equipment, with explicit life-safety and grid-interconnect carve-outs. Office may codify in two paragraphs (e.g., one for HVAC/BMS, one for energy/EV) — pre-position with that fallback. EV charging and commercial HVAC are the highest-confidence sub-categories; solar/battery face heaviest opposition; all are supported under the unified frame.Streamlined renewal is a short "no relevant change in circumstances; no marketplace alternatives have emerged" petition. Assign one person to batch all of these — about 2 days total.
| Class | Topic |
|---|---|
| (b)(1)–(b)(3) | Motion pictures — criticism/comment clips; captioning & audio description; preservation/replacement |
| (b)(4) | Motion pictures — TDM research |
| (b)(5) | Literary works (electronic) — TDM research |
| (b)(6) | Literary works + previously published musical notation — accessibility |
| (b)(7) | Medical-device data compilations — patient access |
| (b)(8) | Wireless devices — unlocking |
| (b)(9) | Smartphones & portable all-purpose mobile computing devices — jailbreaking |
| (b)(10) | Smart televisions — jailbreaking |
| (b)(11) | Voice assistant devices — jailbreaking |
| (b)(12) | Routers and dedicated network devices — jailbreaking |
| (b)(13) | Motorized land vehicles AND marine vessels — diagnosis/repair/lawful modification |
| (b)(14) | Motorized land vehicles AND marine vessels — owner access to operational/diagnostic/telematics data |
| (b)(15) | Consumer devices generally — diagnosis/maintenance/repair |
| (b)(16) | Retail-level commercial food preparation equipment — diagnosis/maintenance/repair |
| (b)(17) | Medical devices and systems — diagnosis/maintenance/repair |
| (b)(18) | Good-faith security research |
| (b)(19) | Video games — preservation when authentication server abandoned |
| (b)(20) | Software preservation by libraries/archives/museums |
| (b)(21) | 3D printers — feedstock interoperability |
| (b)(22) | FOSS computer programs — investigation of potential license infringement |
| Filing | Likely outcome |
|---|---|
| 1 · Ag & Construction | Granted. Possibly with separate paragraphs for stationary-ag and stationary-construction. Mobile-construction clarification recorded. |
| 2 · Scientific & Laboratory Equipment | Granted. Cleanest filing in the portfolio — deliberate 2024 carve-out means no prior denial and no organized opposition. Direct (b)(17) medical-device analog. |
| 3 · American Re-industrialization | 1–2 of 4 sub-asks granted — most likely abandoned-vendor (3b) plus one of regulated-pharma (3a) or factory-floor (3c). Others build 2030 record. Re-industrialization framing may produce sympathetic Register dicta even where scope is denied. |
| 4 · General-Purpose Computing & Networking | Partial grant. Strongest case: commercial workstations + PCs (outside (b)(15)'s consumer gate). Datacenter / enterprise IT denied at full scope; abandoned-vendor IT carve-out plausible. |
| 5 · Commercial Premises Equipment | Single (b)(N), likely codified in 1–2 paragraphs. The unified user-community frame and the device-agnostic 2017 Register recommendation both support breadth. Strongest sub-categories under the unified class: commercial HVAC, EV charging. Heavier opposition on solar/battery; record depth across categories carries the filing as a whole. |
Net new substantive grants: ~3–5 classes. For comparison, 2024 produced 3 substantively-new grants (food-prep, vehicle/vessel data, plus expansions). Every denial's record enables a 2030 grant — the 2024 food-prep grant was built on the 2021 commercial/industrial denial's record. We are explicitly running the same play across five filings.
These came up in scoping but are not in the 5-filing list either because (a) they are plausibly already covered by an existing class and only need testing, (b) they lack a coalition lead, or (c) they would dilute a more-focused filing. Worth a re-look before petitions are frozen.
The FDA's August 2022 OTC rule created a consumer market that didn't exist in any prior §1201 cycle. Fitting and pairing locked behind manufacturer software (Phonak Target, Oticon Genie); battery and shell repair locked. Plausibly already reached by (b)(17) medical-device (prescription side) or (b)(15) consumer-device (OTC side) — but never specifically tested on the record. A short clarifying filing could resolve the ambiguity.
DJI-dominated market with parts authentication, battery-pack pairing, motor/ESC pairing. Consumer drones plausibly reach (b)(15); commercial drones (ag mapping, surveying, professional cinematography) fall into the same commercial/industrial gap that swallowed the 2024 Class 5 broad ask. Could be folded into Filing 3 if a coalition lead emerges.
Milwaukee, DeWalt, EGO, etc. Battery authentication + tool-pairing chips. Consumer-grade plausibly covered by (b)(15); the contractor / job-site tier, which dominates the market, sits in the commercial/industrial gap. Candidate to fold into Filing 1 (construction) if scope permits.
Kindle jailbreaking was denied 2015 for interoperability purposes. Repair (battery replacement de-authentication, paired screens) is a separate question that has never been on the §1201 record. Probably folded into (b)(15) consumer-devices on its face, but untested.
Originally a parking-lot item refreshing the 2012 SFLC PC-repair denial. Now part of Filing 4 (General-Purpose Computing & Networking), which targets the gap that (b)(15)'s "primarily designed for consumers" gate leaves for PCs / Macs / workstations in commercial use.
The "broad class" objection is pretext for "thin record." The Office uses non-cohesive-class language as cover when it wants to deny but doesn't want to commit to a substantive holding. The actual decision variable is record depth: classes that lost the broad-class objection (2021 Class 12, 2024 Class 5 broader scope) also had thin records; classes that won despite breadth (vehicles 2015, consumer devices 2018, medical devices 2021) had concrete, named-witness, named-incident records. Counter the broad-class objection by building the record, not by shrinking scope. And cite the 2017 §1201 Study at PDF p. 94: the Office "recommends against limiting an exemption to specific technologies or devices" — that's the Office's own view that breadth is desirable.
Specific examples build the record; they don't argue for separate filings. When a filing names twelve equipment categories under one class, each category is a record-depth contribution. The diversity of examples is the argument that the class needs to be broad. Splitting into twelve filings would mis-frame what is a single systemic problem.
Round 1 comments (~Dec 2026) is the deadline that matters, not the petition itself. The petition is short. Plan the next 6 months around Round 1 — that's where the record is built.
Treat denials as 2030 raw material. Every "insufficient record" denial tells you exactly what evidence to develop for the next cycle. The 2024 food-prep grant was built on the 2021 commercial/industrial denial — same play, run again at scale here.
The Register's permanent-exemption recommendation is the political backdrop. The 2017 §1201 Study recommended Congress adopt a permanent statutory repair exemption (PDF pp. 88–96). Congress has not acted. That recommendation is still sitting there — every triennial repair win builds the case that the rulemaking is doing work Congress should have made permanent (and which the Freedom To Fix Act would do directly). Cite the Register's own recommendation whenever opposition argues a class is "too broad" or "should wait for legislation": the Office's own view is that the rulemaking is "ill-fitting" for these issues and that broader, device-agnostic protection is what the statute eventually needs. Triennial wins are the bridge.
Professional A/V / broadcast / cinema equipment. Distinct copyright concerns (these devices process audiovisual works); needs careful framing around device-control firmware that does NOT touch access-to-works. Should be its own filing with its own coalition (Society of Broadcast Engineers, post-production trade groups). Not included now to avoid diluting the five focused 2027 filings.
Primary sources are the cycle Final Rules and Registers' Recommendations under 1201/Final Rules/ and 1201/Reg Recommendation/. Key citations:
1201/first-round-comments/2024/Class05_Public-Knowledge.txt), "medical, scientific, or consumer use should remain outside the scope of this class."37 CFR §201.40(b)(13)–(b)(17) and (b)(21).analysis/lineages.json (Layer 2 of the data layer; see AGENTS.md).1201/Claude Reports/2026-05-23__2027-Cycle-Multi-Class-Petition-Plan.md.